The Murder of Antoinette Smith: Inside Ireland’s Forgotten Concert Mystery

Ice Studio
Aug 6
6 min read

Updated: Aug 17

It was the summer of 1987, the kind of night that sticks in memory. Dublin was alive with music, and David Bowie was in town performing at the RDS. Thousands flocked to the venue, including 27-year-old Antoinette “Angie” Smith, a mother of two from Clondalkin.

She wasn’t a reckless teenager. She was a woman balancing work, motherhood, and the small joys of life. For her, this concert was an escape. She dressed for the night, laughed with friends, and immersed herself in Bowie’s electric performance.

I often imagine her in that crowd: singing along, smiling, unaware that this would be the last time anyone would see her alive.

At first, nothing seemed unusual. After the show, she left with friends, caught a lift back toward Clondalkin, and said her goodbyes. She was supposed to continue home. But she never arrived.

The First Hours: When Worry Turns Into Fear

Antoinette’s disappearance didn’t fit the usual profile of a runaway or a late-night accident. She was responsible, reliable, and deeply connected to her daughters. When she didn’t come home, alarm bells should have rung immediately.

But this was Ireland in the late 1980s. Adults went missing all the time, and the Gardee often treated such cases with frustrating caution. “Maybe she stayed out,” they said. “Maybe she needed space.”

Her family knew better.

When I read the first missing-persons notes, what struck me was how quickly her loved ones insisted something was wrong. They knew Antoinette’s patterns, her priorities. And mothers of two don’t just disappear into thin air after a concert.

Still, the official urgency wasn’t there.

And as those first days slipped into weeks, the silence became unbearable.

Nine Months of Not Knowing

For nine long months, Antoinette’s name lingered in the newspapers, but her case slipped further down the priority list. Tips trickled in, most of them dead ends. Some claimed sightings in Wicklow, others in Dublin, none of them confirmed.

Those nine months are worth pausing on. Imagine them from her family’s perspective. Every knock at the door, every phone call, a potential lead. And yet nothing.

Psychologists who study ambiguous loss—when families are left in limbo without confirmation of death—often say it is the hardest grief of all. You can’t mourn fully, and you can’t hope fully. You live in between.

That was the Smith family’s reality. Until April 1988.

The Body in the Wicklow Mountains

On April 3, 1988, walkers in the Sally Gap area of the Wicklow Mountains made a grim discovery. Buried in a shallow grave was Antoinette’s body.

The location wasn’t random. Wicklow had long been a place associated with secrecy—remote, wooded, isolated. If you wanted to hide something in Ireland in the 1980s, Wicklow was where you went.

Her body was concealed, not discarded. That detail matters. It suggests the killer cared enough to hide her, to delay discovery. This wasn’t a crime of sudden rage where someone left the victim where she fell. This was methodical. Planned.

And it raised the first of many chilling questions: who had the knowledge and nerve to carry out a burial in such a remote spot, under cover of night?

What the Evidence Revealed—and What It Didn’t

Forensics in 1988 weren’t what they are today. Chain of custody was looser, DNA testing was limited, and soil analysis was rudimentary. Still, investigators noted important details:

The body was deliberately buried, showing forethought.
Tool marks were present in the soil, suggesting a spade or similar equipment.
Items of clothing suggested she had not been randomly abandoned.

And then came the most haunting point: there were no witnesses, no sightings, no clear suspects.

The Bowie concert had drawn thousands. Yet among all those people, the last moments of Antoinette’s life vanished into obscurity.

A Pattern in the Shadows?

As I dug deeper, I noticed something investigators themselves would later acknowledge: Antoinette’s case wasn’t isolated.

In the years surrounding her disappearance, other young women in Ireland vanished after concerts, festivals, or late-night gatherings. Some were found murdered. Others were never found at all.

Was it coincidence? Or the shadow of something darker—a serial predator using concerts as hunting grounds?

This theory may sound sensational, but patterns don’t lie. Antoinette’s case was just one in a troubling cluster stretching from Dublin to Wicklow.

And yet, at the time, Gardee investigated each case separately. No links. No dots connected.

The Missed Opportunities

When I review the original investigation files, what stands out isn’t just what was found—it’s what wasn’t.

Witness canvassing around the RDS was minimal.
Taxi drivers and concert staff weren’t systematically interviewed.
Rumors about a suspicious van near the concert site never solidified into leads.

It feels almost unforgivable.

Because when you consider the psychological profile of the killer—organized, cautious, methodical—the opportunities to catch him early were there. They just weren’t seized.

Theories That Refuse to Die

Over the decades, several theories have emerged:

The Known Acquaintance TheoryDid Antoinette leave with someone she trusted? Killers who conceal bodies often have a prior relationship with their victims.
The Stranger Predator TheorySome suggest a predatory man targeted her at the concert, followed her, and lured her into a vehicle. Wicklow’s remoteness hints at someone familiar with the terrain.
The Serial ConnectionOthers point to similarities with disappearances near Slane concerts and Wicklow routes. Could one killer have stalked multiple women in Ireland during that era?

Each theory holds weight. None have been conclusively proven.

Psychological Profile: Who Could Do This?

If we build a psychological sketch from what we know:

Organized offender: deliberate burial, remote location, tools prepared.
Control-driven personality: concealment suggests a desire to maintain dominance even after death.
Possible familiarity with victim or area: Wicklow wasn’t chosen randomly.

What chills me most is how ordinary the suspect might appear. Killers like this often blend in—neighbors, co-workers, even family men.

The Human Toll

We cannot forget the core truth: two daughters grew up without their mother. Parents buried a child. Friends never had closure.

When I spoke to locals years later, many said the same thing: It could have been any of us. That was the terror. Antoinette wasn’t reckless. She wasn’t in the wrong place at the wrong time. She was just living her life.

And that is what makes this case so haunting.

Why Antoinette’s Case Still Matters

True crime isn’t about voyeurism—it’s about memory and justice. Antoinette Smith’s case represents a failure of the system: missed leads, unconnected dots, and an unsolved murder that might still hold answers if someone, somewhere, speaks.

Cold cases are being cracked worldwide thanks to new DNA technology, genealogy databases, and advanced forensic soil testing. If investigators revisit Antoinette’s remains, clothing, or the burial site with today’s tools, they might yet uncover evidence invisible in 1988.

Similar Cold Cases in Ireland

Annie McCarrick (1993): An American student vanished in Dublin; last seen heading toward Wicklow. Still unsolved.
Deirdre Jacob (1998): A young woman disappeared near her home in Newbridge. Declared a murder inquiry, but no conviction.
JoJo Dullard (1995): Missing after hitchhiking in Kildare. Believed to be a victim of foul play.

Each of these cases shares threads with Antoinette’s: women disappearing in or around Wicklow, at night, with no trace.

Final Reflections

The story of Antoinette Smith isn’t just a murder mystery. It’s a mirror held up to Ireland in the 1980s—a society where women vanished and weren’t always given the urgency they deserved.

Her case lingers like a shadow because it was never solved. It lingers because we know someone out there carried her into the Wicklow Mountains and buried her. And it lingers because silence still protects that person.

When I think of Antoinette, I picture the moment after the Bowie concert ended: crowds dispersing, laughter echoing, cars pulling away. Somewhere in that swirl of normality, a predator made their move.

And more than thirty years later, we are still asking: who was it, and why have they never been caught?

true crime, Ireland cold case, Antoinette Smith murder, Wicklow Mountains murder, David Bowie concert mystery, Irish unsolved murders, missing women Ireland, Gardee investigation, unsolved murder mystery

Sources